The Deaths at Gitmo
EDITORIAL, NYTimes on
the Web, June 12, 2006
The news that three inmates at
Guantánamo Bay hanged themselves should not have surprised anyone who has paid
the slightest attention to the twisted history of the camp that President Bush
built for selected prisoners from Afghanistan and antiterrorist operations.n
It was the inevitable result of creating a netherworld of despair beyond the
laws of civilized nations, where men were to be held without any hope of decent
treatment, impartial justice or, in so many cases, even eventual release.
It is a place where secret tribunals sat in judgment of men whose identities
they barely knew and who were not permitted to see the evidence against them.
Inmates were abused, humiliated, tormented and sometimes tortured. Some
surely are very dangerous men, committed to a life of terrorism and deserving of
harsh justice. But only 10 of the roughly 465 men at the camp have been
charged with crimes. The others, according to senior officers who served
there, were foot soldiers of the Taliban or men who just happened to live in a
country invaded by the United States after the 9/11 attacks.
Inmates at Guantánamo Bay have tried seeking help from the American courts, and
one case has reached the Supreme Court. But most of these appeals were
thwarted by claims of national security. Any new appeals will fall under a
shocking new law that deprives the inmates of the centuries-old right to
challenge their imprisonment. Government lawyers have even tried to use
that law retroactively, to dismiss all pending appeals.
Guantánamo Bay and other American detention centers have sparked outrage around
the world — deeply harming America's image as the defender of humanity against
just these sorts of abuses. Last month a United Nations panel called for
the prisons to be shut down. But the administration's response to all of
this has been defiance.
When dozens of inmates went on hunger strikes last year, the authorities
strapped them into metal "restraint chairs" and ordered doctors to force-feed
them. Military officials said they did this only to inmates on the brink
of death, but The Times has reported that the restraint chair was used on all
hunger strikers, regardless of their condition.
Medical groups were overwhelmingly appalled by this practice, but the Pentagon
issued new rules this month reaffirming that military doctors can be ordered to
force-feed prisoners. The only role for psychiatrists at Gitmo seems to be
to help prepare prisoners for interrogation.
So it was not surprising in the least when inmates attempted suicide.
Twenty-three tried to kill themselves over eight days in August 2003, but the
military covered it up for 18 months. Now, three inmates have succeeded.
Camp officials say one was a mid- or high-level Qaeda operative. One was
captured in Afghanistan (doing what, we're not sure), and the other was from
something the camp commander, Rear Adm. Harry Harris Jr., called a splinter
group.
Admiral Harris's response was as appalling as the suicides. "I believe
this was not an act of desperation, but an act of asymmetrical warfare waged
against us," he said. The inmates, he said, "have no regard for life,
neither ours nor their own."
These comments reveal a profound disassociation from humanity. They say
more about why Guantánamo Bay should be closed than any United Nations report
ever could.
|
