Bush Vetoes Stem Cell
Bill As Promised
By MARY DALRYMPLE, AP
from washingtonpost.com on the Web, July 19, 2006
WASHINGTON -- President Bush
cast the first veto of his presidency Wednesday, saying legislation easing
limits on federal funding for embryonic stem cell research "crosses a moral
boundary."
"This bill would support the taking of innocent human life in the hope of
finding medical benefits for others," Bush said at a White House event where he
was surrounded by 18 families who "adopted" frozen embryos not used by other
couples, and then used those leftover embryos to have children.
"Each of these children was still adopted while still an embryo and has been
blessed with a chance to grow, to grow up in a loving family. These boys and
girls are not spare parts," he said.
The veto came a day after the Senate defied Bush and approved the legislation,
63-37, four votes short of the two-thirds margin needed to override. White House
officials and Republican congressional leaders claimed it was unlikely that
Congress could override the veto.
Bush's support was the strongest in the House, which was expected to take up the
veto as early as later Wednesday.
"We will go back and sustain his veto this afternoon," veto supporter Rep. Joe
Pitts, R-Pa., told reporters at the White House after the event. "We had
52 votes to spare when it passed and I predict the House will sustain that
veto."
Bush has supported federally funded research on only those stem cell lines
created before Aug. 9, 2001, the date of his speech to the nation on the
subject.
The president vetoed the measure shortly after it came to his desk. His
position was politically popular among conservative Republicans, and it was sure
to be an issue in the midterm congressional elections.
Announcing the veto, Bush was surrounded in the East Room by so-called
"snowflake" families, those with children born through embryo donation.
"They remind us of what is lost when embryos are destroyed in the name of
research. They remind us that we all begin our lives as a small collection
of cells. And they remind us that in our zeal for new treatments and
cures, America must never abandon our fundamental morals," Bush said.
He said the bill would have crossed a line and "once crossed, we would find it
impossible to turn back."
At the same time, Bush announced he had signed another bill, passed unanimously
in the House and Senate, that would pre-emptively ban "fetal farming," the
prospect of raising and aborting fetuses for scientific research.
Moments after Bush spoke, the vetoed legislation was returned to Congress.
Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., was quick to criticize the
president's veto.
"I am pro-life, but I disagree with the president's decision to veto the Stem
Cell Research Enhancement Act," said Frist. "Given the potential of this
research and the limitations of the existing lines eligible for federally funded
research, I think additional lines should be made available."
Said Bush: "As science brings us every closer to unlocking the secrets of
human biology, it also offers temptations to manipulate human life and violate
human dignity. Our conscience in history as a nation demand that we resist
this temptation.
"America was founded on the principle that we are all created equal and endowed
by our creator with the right to life," he added. "We can advance the
cause of science while upholding this founding promise. We can harness the
promise of technology without becoming slaves to technology. And we can
ensure that science serves the cause of humanity, instead of the other way
around."
Pleadings from celebrities, a former first lady and fellow Republicans had
failed to move Bush. He acted after two days of often wrenching emotional
debate in Congress, punctuated by stories of personal and family suffering, that
had cast lawmakers into the intersection of politics, morality and science.
Strong majorities in the House and Senate joined sentiments with most Americans
in passing the bill, which would have lifted restriction currently limiting
federally funded research to stem cell lines created before Aug. 9, 2001.
"I expect that the House will sustain the president's veto," said House Majority
Leader John Boehner, R-Ohio, said in advance of Bush's action.
Disappointed lawmakers said they intended to keep pushing to lift the
restrictions.
Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah said in advance that the veto "sets back embryonic stem
cell research another year or so."
The Senate voted 63-37 on Tuesday, four votes short of the two-thirds majority
that would be needed to override a veto. The House last year fell 50 votes
short of a veto-proof margin when it passed the same bill, 238-194.
Bush had made 141 veto threats during his time in office, and the Republicans
controlling Congress typically respond by changing bills to his liking.
Bush's stand against embryonic stem cell research is popular among conservative
Republicans whom the party will rely on in the congressional elections this
fall. Many of those opponents are the same voters who have felt alienated
by Bush's actions to increase legal immigration, and the veto could bring them
back into the fold.
Although many in the religious right are passionately opposed to embryonic stem
cell research, most Americans support it, and Bush risks alienating that
majority in the critical midterm year.
On the Net:
Information on the bills, H.R. 810, S. 3504 and S. 2754, may be found at
http://thomas.loc.gov
|
